416 Noisy (Part 2)
"Dear all comrades of the Central Executive Committee of the Communist International, and all comrades of the Central Committee of the Bolsheviks of the Russian Bolsheviks. I only send a letter to you on behalf of the Central Committee of the Communist Party of Germany... On International Labor Day, May 1, on this day of the proletariat all over the world, the German Communist Party led the working class in Berlin to make an attempt, and an experiment with profound significance... Before this, we once thought that the working class in Germany was strong enough to shoulder the mission entrusted to them by history... But the bloody reality taught us a truth that our enemies were still very strong, the bourgeoisie and the Junker landlords had colluded together and had begun to suppress the people bloodily..."
This is a summary report submitted by the German Communist Party on the Second Berlin Uprising. In this report, Liebknesi, Luxembourg and Zetkin profoundly summarized the experiences and lessons of the failure of the uprising. The self-criticism is quite profound. In this report, the German Communist Party believes that the failure of the uprising has both subjective and objective reasons.
Subjectively: The German Communist Party was not prepared enough and did not fully recognize the cruelty of the struggle. Objectively: The strength of the German bourgeoisie and Juncker landlords needs to be re-evaluated, and they are much stronger than expected. In short, this report is still relatively objective, and Luxembourg and Liebknesi have also found the reason for their failure.
To put it bluntly, that is, the power of the German working class is overestimated!
Although the German and Communist Party did not directly make this conclusion, the subtext in the entire report actually means this. When Lenin read out the three heavy names signed for the report, the Trotskyist face was quite exciting.
Trotsky was just shouting for the German Communist Party, exonerating them, and attributed the reason for the failure of the uprising to the uniting of world imperialism to strangle the German revolution. However, immediately, the German Communist Party’s own report said that the fundamental reason for the failure was to underestimate the power of the enemy. Although these two statements have some similar components, the meaning is completely different. The German Communist Party mentioned that the issue of world imperialism was not mentioned. The enemies they referred to were only the bourgeoisie and Junker landlords in Germany.
In other words, Germany itself denied the conclusion drawn by Trotsky, and they admitted their shortcomings frankly.
For Trotsays, this is really deadly. They are working hard to support the German brothers and help them whitewash them. Okay, how can you reveal that they are ugly? Isn’t this a pig teammate?
In an instant, the Leninists were relieved. With the report from the German Communist Party, it would be useless to hide Trotsky no matter how you conceal it. You can't deny the conclusions you made, right?
You can't say that the Trotskyists really dare to do this. For them, the German revolution is the lifeblood, and they have to keep it even if they give up their face. Ulitsky immediately jumped out: "The summary report of the comrades of the German Communist Party is too subjective. They failed to correctly understand the root cause of the failure. Such a report is only of reference value!"
Sverdlov immediately sarcastically: "If the summary report of German comrades is too subjective, then your summary is simply pure imagination and pure self-righteousness. Can the comrades in Germany not even understand what their enemies are? Do they in Germany do not understand the situation better than those of us who are thousands of kilometers away?"
Ulitzki also took the initiative: "There is an ancient Chinese poem that says that you don't know the true face of Mount Lu because you are born in this mountain. Many times, outsiders may see it more clearly than insiders!"
Sverdlov sarcastically said: "There is not only you, Comrade Ulitzki. So many comrades present are outsiders. How many agree with your statement?"
Bukharin quickly interrupted, "This is not a matter of number of people..."
Stalin immediately interrupted him: "This is the question of number of people. When most comrades, including those in Germany, reach a universal consensus, this consensus should be recognized! Otherwise, what else can we do in a meeting? Let's do our own things and then we will end!"
Trotsky was forced to speak again, "Of course the report of German comrades needs to be paid attention to, but this does not mean that we have to doubt the strength of the working class of the German Communist Party, and we have to question the routes of the Eighth National Congress!"
Zinoviev sneered and said sarcastically: "First of all, you are the one who questioned the eight major routes and established strategies. Comrade Trotsky? The eight major resolutions are clearly written. Before eliminating the bandit army in China, it is not advisable to be directly involved in the revolutionary struggle of Germany. You must fully believe in the power of the German working class. Have you forgotten these?"
Since Trotsky made a move on the Estonian issue last time, Zinoviev hated Lao Tuo. He would sing a counter-topic with him whenever he had the chance, and would sarcastically mock him. Now Lao Tuo has brought his own handle to the door, how could he be polite?
Trotsky was speechless again. The situation was quite unfavorable to him. If he wanted to directly assist the German Revolution and directly dispatch military forces to intervene, he would inevitably overturn the relevant resolutions of the Eighth National Congress. The resolutions on the German Revolution at the Eighth National Congress were actually beneficial to him, and Lenin made concessions.
Now, he wants to take the lead and go a step further, and Lenin naturally cannot agree. The tutor’s meaning is very obvious. If you, Trotsky, want to deny the relevant resolutions of the Eighth National Congress, then OK, I will completely deny it and directly overturn your route!
It can be said that Trotsky was unable to advance or retreat at this time. If he denies the relevant resolutions of the Eight Major, then the Lenin faction would completely destroy his theory and line, which would be a complete break. Trotsky naturally did not want to see such a situation. Without the cooperation of the Lenin faction, it would be impossible for him to show his strength. Without denying the resolutions of the Eight Major and following the established policy, it would be hard to say how many days the German revolution could last. This is also something he did not want to see.
Trotsky was silent, and the Trotskyists naturally became silent. As for the Leninists, they didn't dare to force them too much. Everyone was a grasshopper on the same rope, and no one could do without each other. Although it was simple to split up, they really couldn't bear the consequences!
In this tangled situation, there is probably only one person who is very happy, that is Kamenev. This guy has always ignored the overall situation and only cared for his own interests. He wished that the situation would be better and better. It would be better that the Trotskyists and the Leninists would immediately start to become popular.
So he once again stood up and added fuel to the fire: "The relevant resolutions of the Eighth National Congress are already problematic. Now, correcting the mistakes of the Eighth National Congress is the attitude of being responsible for the revolution. I think the relevant resolutions should be discussed again and a new resolution that is truly beneficial to the revolution!"
In the eyes of the Leninists, Kamenev was labeled as Trotsky at this time. This guy speaks on behalf of Trotsky. You have officially started to undermine the situation, so you can be polite to you!
Stalin, who was most angry, immediately stood up and prepared to open fire on the Trotsay with all his might. Just before he spoke, Lenin suddenly spoke again: "I just read the summary report of the Central Committee of the Communist Party of Germany. There is also a call for help from them here."
As he said that, Lenin began to recite again: "...What the German revolution urgently needs is not foreign military interference, but military interference is a Pandora's box. Although we are very happy that Russian comrades lend a helping hand, this will give international imperialists a justification, so that they can also send troops to interfere in our revolution... Judging from the current situation, direct military interference is the least needed and the most dangerous. We hope that Russian comrades can provide us with assistance in funding, weapons and organizations. We need funds for armed struggles, weapons, and especially consultants with war experience to help us build a proletarian army..."
The Trotsays were speechless again. They have always said that the German comrades need reinforcements and direct assistance from the Red Army. But now it seems that they don’t think so at all. They don’t want foreign troops at all, and at most they need military advisers. This makes the Trotsay feel like they are wearing a hot face and cold butt.
In fact, the Trotskyists have always been a hot face and cold butt. Liebknecht and Luxembourg are communists, and they have noble internationalist sentiments, but at the same time they also insist on Germany's independence and autonomy.
In fact, the Trotskyists have always been a hot face and cold butt. Liebknesi and Luxembourg are communists and have noble internationalist sentiments, but at the same time they also insist on Germany's independence and independence. For them, the German revolution should always be dominated by the Germans, and they refuse to become vassals of other forces, even if this force is a brother party from other countries!
But the Trotskyists ignored this point and thought that as long as they strongly support it, the German Communist Party had no reason to be unhappy. Who would have thought that reality was not the case at all. Germans have the pride of Germans, and they never intended or were willing to rely on others or rely on others.
Not only Germans, but every nation in the world that pursues does not like "good intentions" like Trotskyism. Only those nations that do not pursue and like to show off will accept similar good intentions.
You should know that in the article "On the Russian Revolution", Luxembourg criticized Lenin and Trotsky's national resolution without mercy, believing that the right to national self-determination greatly hindered Russia's national sovereignty. On this issue, Luxembourg's vigilance was not ordinary, so how could she accept Trotsky's kindness and give the fate of the German revolution to Lao Tzu completely?
I have to say that Lao Tuo was a great failure in this regard. He only saw the advantages of the continuous revolutionary theory, but did not expect that others would accept it or not. Once others did not accept his "good intention", what should I do?
Then there is no way to do it. Anyway, after Lenin read the German comrade's request, the Trotsay suddenly became depressed. People were so straightforward, almost like a slap in the face. What's the point of persisting?
But there is another person who is ignorant, that is Kamenev. The guy shouted: "The German revolution is not just a matter of the German working class! It is part of the world revolution, and the problem of the German revolution cannot be viewed in isolation... The world revolution is a big game, and the German revolution is just a piece on the chessboard. The world revolution is led by the Communist International, and the German revolution must also be commanded by the Communist International! How can the German comrades make trouble at will? If the proletariat in the world are like this, what else should the Communist International do? Wouldn't it be empty talk to the proletariat in the world unite?"
This made the Trotskyist eyes lit up, but Lenin's next sentence dimmed their eyes: "The Communist International has made arrangements for the German revolution long ago, giving full play to the subjective initiative of German comrades and letting them lead the German working class to carry out revolutionary struggles. This is an established policy!"
Before Kamenev refuted, Lenin emphasized his tone again: "And the world revolution is a big game, but the proletarian parties and proletariats in all countries that make up this big game are not pawns. The Communist International is only responsible for macro-control, not specific command... The national conditions of each country are different, and the specific situations they have to face are different. How can it be used for remote control command?"
Kamenev had nothing to say. Although he wanted to continue saying something, there was no excuse. As for Trotsky, there was no good idea. Unless he really wanted to turn the table and start the stove, he could only accept this result.
At least respect the requirements of the German Communist Party, and do not involve overthrowing the resolution of the Eighth Congress. Everyone can continue to work together under this framework. Of course, this does not mean that he does not say anything, he still has to continue to fight for it.
"We should fully respect the decisions of the Central Committee of the Communist Party of Germany and meet all their requirements. Especially the requirements of sending military advisers, this should be met first!" Trotsky waved his hand suddenly: "I suggest that the elites be drawn from the Red Army immediately and send them to Germany as soon as possible!"
The bosses of the Trotskyists all spoke, and the other little brothers naturally agreed. They talked about the importance of military advisers one by one, and they wanted to send the commander of the Red Army all over the place.
In fact, Trotsky also made this plan. He decided to use military advisers to do something. Sending military advisers would definitely be approved by the Central Committee. As long as he had this excuse, he could openly repair the plank road and secretly travel to Chencang.
How to secretly travel to Chen Cang? It's very simple. Trotsky decided to pass a relatively vague resolution, that is, to pass only the resolution to send military advisers, without mentioning the number of military advisers. One and two are also military advisers, one thousand or ten thousand, and that is still military advisers. Trotsky planned to send him tens of thousands of military advisers to Germany!
To be honest, this idea is very good, but I underestimated the political wisdom of Lenin, Sverdlov and Stalin, and watched Trotsky perform there. They were secretly funny. Can you take this trick on the top? This fully shows that you, Trotsky, have no way to do it!
"How many military advisers will be sent?" Stalin broke Trotsky's plan with one sentence.
Trotsky tsked in his heart and said helplessly: "The German working class has no rich experience in fighting, so the number of military advisers should be a little more!"
Sverdlov would not be polite to him: "How much is a little more? There must be an exact number, right?"
Trotsky was still preparing to fool around: "It depends on the needs of German comrades, and it can be discussed by the Supreme Military Commission..."
"There is no need!" Lenin interrupted him directly, "Call the Central Committee of the Communist Party of Germany and ask how many military advisers they need!"
"this……"
Trotsky was so angry. Seeing that Xiao Si and Stalin were not easy to fool, he was ready to use the Military Commission to make a fuss. After all, he was a little more powerful in the Military Commission. The so-called decision after the Military Commission was studied and discussed. In fact, it was equivalent to his personal intention. But Lenin did not give him this opportunity at all, and kicked the ball to the German Communist Party with one kick. According to Germany's previous attitude, there was no need to think about the military advisory group of tens of thousands of people, and it was impossible for thousands of people, at most it was only hundreds.
Trotsky was angry and anxious, but he couldn't disrespect the decision of the Central Committee of the German Communist Party. He couldn't force the military adviser to pass over, right?
In desperation, Trotsky had to settle for the second best. If he couldn't give him a person, he would give him more guns!
"Ten thousand rifles, one hundred machine guns and supporting ammunition should be allocated as soon as possible! The situation of the revolution will not wait for anyone!"
Trotsky sighed in a pretentious manner and emphasized: "This is only the first batch of weapons to support the German working class. We should give the second and third batch of military aid according to the circumstances!"
If he only wants guns and bullets, Lenin would not be stingy. As long as he doesn't ask for someone, tens of thousands of rifles and hundreds of machine guns can still be afforded. As long as he can keep Trotsmen calm for two days and as long as he can get more time to eliminate the bandits in the country, he will regard it as a loss of money and avoid disaster.
So after the emergency meeting, he specially found Stalin and talked alone, demanding that Steel must speed up the removal of Denikin. Every extra day of delay would lead to a more night dream! God knows when Trotsky would play tricks again.
"Do you want to explain to Comrade Andre and let him pay more attention to the developments in Germany?" Xiao Si suggested.
Anyone can hear that what Xiao Si said to pay more attention to the development of Germany is definitely not entirely referring to the development of the German revolution, but more attention to the Trotsky's movements in this regard, so as not to make trouble from time to time to disgust people.
Lenin shook his head and said, "The focus is not on Germany now, but on the domestic. However, paying attention to the situation in Germany is not a bad thing. Tell Andre that work abroad should be more meticulous and be impatient! By the way, tell him the key point not to try to rescue Comrade Yue Fei and Comrade Radick. That is not the core issue. If the overall situation is delayed in order to rescue them, it will be more worth the loss!"
Is Lenin not helping him? No, as the saying goes, the two countries are fighting each other without killing them. Although the Albert government cut off diplomatic relations with Russia and detained Yue Fei and Radick, he would not do anything to them. To put it bluntly, this is just Albert showing his attitude, and he will naturally release him when the time comes.
In fact, Lenin's order was also a waste of time. Li Xiaofeng had no intention of saving those two guys at all...
PS: Bow to thank the traveler who follows the wind, the wanderer in the south, Juventus, instantly killing potatoes, Admiral Hood and Comrade Bobo!
Chapter completed!