Chapter 0134 Free refutation
At this time, everyone in the audience was paying close attention to the eight people in the debate.
The fun is about to begin.
What kind of scene will happen next?
Everyone is looking forward to it.
The debate lasted for so long, and Ye Shilang, the fourth debater, did not say a word.
The previous results are the result of the hard work and hard work of the teammates.
You must control yourself well in the last two stages, and you must not make any mistakes.
The scene of the debate I had in my first year of high school is still vivid in my mind.
Now I am standing on the debate field again, hoping to use some valuable experience to help my teammates overcome this difficulty.
Ye Shilang realized that the most critical moment of the battle between the two sides had arrived.
Moderator: "Please speak first."
Ye Shilang and classmates Haiting, Tang Lili, and Sun Yuer made eye contact respectively.
It strengthened the confidence of teammates.
Ye Shilang stood up without thinking. At this time, he had to pick up the fight.
The three teammates have already been under a lot of pressure.
Ye Shilang said: "Hello everyone, I am Ye Shilang, the fourth debater of the square."
There were people whispering in the audience.
"Ye Shilang, wasn't that the best debater in the first year of high school two years ago?"
"Yes, it's him. I didn't expect to see his performance again today."
"Well, now it's interesting to see."
"Both sides are very powerful. It's hard to say who will win."
"Stop talking and watch carefully, hush."
...
Ye Shilang: "The opponent's fellow debater insists on the view that loyalty and filial piety cannot have both sides since ancient times. The emphasis is on ancient times."
"However, time has passed and the world has developed to this day. Technology and social civilization are no longer what they used to be."
"Loyalty and filial piety cannot have both ends. Looking at it now, there is obviously no basis for it."
"In other words, in a modern society where society is highly developed, it is very easy to achieve both loyalty and filial piety. What do you think of this?"
Liu Zhaocai, the opponent of the fourth debate, also stood up. It seemed that every round was a battle of positions.
Liu Zhaocai: "Loyalty and filial piety cannot have both. It is true whether it is ancient or modern. What Zhengfang said is easy to implement. I don't know where it comes from? Just now, the four arguments of Zhengfang mentioned that since ancient times, loyalty and filial piety cannot have both, and it can only be established in ancient times. So,
Does Zhengfang also admit that in ancient times, loyalty and filial piety could not be both balanced?"
Haiting thought for a moment and quickly took over the words, "We have never admitted that loyalty and filial piety cannot be balanced. There are many examples of loyalty and filial piety in ancient times. The one mentioned above is Bao Qingtian, and the well-known Hua Hua
Mulan joining the army in place of her father, isn't it an eternal story of loyalty and filial piety?"
The opposition reacted quickly, and Hu Jinshan immediately counterattacked: "Mulan joins the army. She is serving the country. She chooses loyalty, but her parents are thousands of miles away in her hometown. How does she maintain her filial piety?
"
Tang Lili seemed to show no sign of weakness and blurted out: "Isn't joining the army on your father's behalf an act of filial piety? Her father was old and could not go to the battlefield to kill the enemy. Mulan did not want to see her father suffer the pain of military service, so she disguised herself as a man and took her father's place.
Joining the army, this kind of filial piety, how come the anti-party debate friends turn a blind eye and listen to it?"
Li Nianhua: "What does Zhengfang mean when he just mentioned that it is easy to achieve both loyalty and filial piety in modern society? Please explain."
Sun Yu'er thought that it was his turn to take action, smiled slightly, and said: "It's not easy to explain. For example, a person works hard to serve the country and is loyal to his duties, but he can use the income he earns to meet his parents' living needs.
, he can support his parents. There is no one to take care of the parents' food and daily life. The children can pay for a nanny. When they miss their parents, they can call them from time to time to report that they are safe. They can also use mobile phones to video chat. The advantages of highly developed technology are not
Is it right here? If it were in ancient times, it would be harder to go home than to go to heaven. Is it true that the understanding ability of the opposing debate friends can't keep up with the pace? "
Xiao Yuzai's answer triggered bursts of laughter from the audience.
The humorous style also infected the audience.
It resonated with many people.
The judges in the audience also nodded in approval.
Xiao Yuzai's speech made the opposition a little bit unable to get off the stage. Li Nianhua, Hu Jinshan, Gan Yufu and Liu Zhaocai all looked blue and white in turns, and they were very confused.
Hu Jinshan did not give up at all and continued to refute: "The positive explanation is really far-fetched. Not every family or everyone can afford a nanny. There is a conflict between loyalty and filial piety in terms of time and space."
Ye Shilang was unmoved after hearing this, and then launched the next offensive, "May I ask my opponent's fellow debater, where is the dilemma between loyalty and filial piety?"
Hu Jinshan: "Be loyal to the country and be filial to your parents. The main object of loyalty is the country, and the main object of filial piety is the parents. The two have an irreconcilable relationship."
Ye Shilang: "So, if the opponent's fellow debater insists that if you are loyal to the country, you cannot be filial to your parents, and if you are filial to your parents, you cannot be loyal to the country, right?"
Liu Zhaocai: "Our point of view is that since ancient times, loyalty and filial piety cannot have both sides. Wise people will selectively give up one of them. Choosing loyalty or filial piety is a man."
Hai Ting: “Isn’t it true that a man is a true man if he has both loyalty and filial piety?”
Li Nianhua: "As Zhengfang said, the rapid development of science and technology in modern society has created a large amount of social wealth and personal assets. In fact, many modern parents do not need material filial piety from their children at all, and they can live a good life themselves.
It is no longer the same as the poverty and backwardness of ancient times. Today’s parents want their children to live a good life, so in modern society, the requirements for everyone’s loyalty and filial piety have been diluted. There is no need to even perform the duties of loyalty and filial piety.”
Tang Lili: "If a person doesn't even have loyalty and filial piety, then what's the use of standing between heaven and earth?"
Ye Shilang: "Please don't deviate from today's debate topic. What we are discussing is whether loyalty and filial piety can be both, not whether loyalty and filial piety should be both."
Hu Jinshan: "Zhengfang has repeatedly insisted on the idea of loyalty and filial piety. I would like to ask, is it wrong to be loyal or filial when you are lacking in ability?"
Ye Shilang: “Please ask the other debater not to impose any additional premise on the debate topic. Today’s debate topic does not talk about the level of personal ability.”
...
The pros and cons came back and forth, fighting each other, the debates were inextricable, and the arguments were exciting.
The 5 minutes are up quickly.
The battle between Ye Shilang's team and the four opponents was still unfinished, and none of them seemed to have any intention of stopping.
Until the moderator announced: "Please note that the time for free debate for both sides is up. Please be ready for the next step."
Ye Shilang calmed down and the free debate finally came to an end. It was really enjoyable.
The last step is to conclude your argument.
Ye Shilang's attention shifted to what he was going to say next.
I hope it can give my team some chances of winning.
The little cute baby didn't know when he appeared, with his big round eyes open, he said:
"Master, come on, we will succeed soon."
Chapter completed!